XL (Party Size) Banoffee Pie Sydney – Peak Banoffee Romance at Legendary Scale

Looking for the best banoffee pie in Sydney…for a crowd?
This is the one that gets talked about before it’s even cut.

Handcrafted fresh in Newtown, Butter and Love’s XL Banoffee Pie takes everything people love about the OG and scales it up to something genuinely unforgettable. With 400+ five star Google reviews and a cult following across Sydney, this is the pie that turns a table into a moment.

Big, bold and completely unapologetic.

Over 5kg of buttery base, luscious dulce de leche caramel, fresh bananas and double thick cream, finished exactly the way your chosen flavour demands.

Simple on paper. Unreal in real life.

Made fresh to order using premium ingredients and obsessive attention to detail, this isn’t just a larger pie. It’s a centrepiece.

This is peak Banoffee romance…on a scale that gets people talking.

---

Available in All Three Banoffee Flavours

Every XL pie carries the same signature layers that made Butter and Love a Sydney favourite, just amplified.

OG Banoffee
The original. Buttery biscuit base, luscious dulce de leche caramel, fresh bananas, double thick vanilla bean cream and hand curled dark chocolate

Biscoff Banoffee
Warm, spiced and dangerously addictive. Buttery Biscoff base, luscious dulce de leche caramel, Biscoff caramelised biscuit spread, fresh bananas, double thick vanilla bean cream and a Biscoff crumb crown

Peanut Butter Banoffee
The salty sweet obsession. Buttery, salty biscuit base, luscious dulce de leche caramel, dark roasted crunchy peanut butter, fresh bananas, double thick peanut butter cream, dutch processed cocoa and peanut brittle

---

Why This XL Banoffee Pie Hits Different

Every layer is doing exactly what it should…and then some:

• Buttery Biscuit Base – golden, toasted and built to hold over 5kg of pure indulgence
• Homemade Dulce de Leche Caramel – slow cooked until deeply caramelised and impossible to ignore
• Additional Layer – dark roasted peanut butter or Biscoff caramelised biscuit spread, depending on your flavour
• Fresh Australian Bananas – hand sliced just before pickup for perfect ripeness and texture
• Double Thick Cream – double thick vanilla bean or peanut butter cream, rich, smooth and finished to that signature cloud consistency
• Finishing Touches – hand curled dark chocolate, Biscoff crumb or Dutch processed cocoa and peanut brittle, depending on your flavour

---

Order Banoffee Pie in Newtown, Sydney's Inner West

All pies are made fresh to order with a minimum 48 hours’ notice.

• Pick Up: Inside Rude Boy Doughnuts, 573 King Street, Newtown NSW 2042

• Trading Days: Thursday to Sunday

• Time: 10am to 2pm (or until sold out)

Limited quantities each week. Once they’re gone, they’re gone.

We focus on pickup only but you’re welcome to organise your own courier if needed.

Pro tip: If it's for an event, don't leave it to the last minute.

---

Why Butter and Love

With 400+ five star reviews, Butter and Love has become a cult favourite for banoffee pie in Sydney.

This isn’t mass produced. It’s a one woman kitchen powered by butter, turning out pies people go out of their way for.

No shortcuts. No artificial flavours. No playing it safe.

Just a buttery base, luscious dulce de leche caramel, cloud like cream, dark chocolate curls and unapologetic indulgence.

---

FAQs

Where can I buy banoffee pie in Sydney?
Right here. Butter and Love is based in Newtown with pickup available Thursday to Sunday.

Do I need to pre-order?
Yes. A minimum of 48 hours’ notice is required as every pie is made fresh to order.

Can I order for a specific date or event?
Yes. You can select your preferred pickup date at checkout as long as it's Thursday to Sunday. We recommend ordering early for weekends and special occasions as availability is limited.

How long does the pie last?
Best enjoyed within 3 days. Always keep refrigerated, remove from the fridge 20 minutes before serving.

Do you offer gluten free options?
Yes, gluten free options are available in all three sizes.

---

Sydney's Best Banoffee Pie

For birthdays, celebrations, dinner parties, or just because you felt like making a very good decision.

This is Sydney’s best banoffee pie, made fresh in Newtown with butter, love and zero restraint.

Order now…before you see it on someone else’s story and wish you did.

XL (Party Size) Banoffee Pie – Sydney’s Ultimate 5kg Showstopper

Handcrafted in Five Dock, Sydney, the XL Party Size Banoffee Pie by Butter and Love is the spectacular, crowd-feeding version of our iconic Banoffee range. If the regular Banoffee is loved, the XL is worshipped. Loved for birthdays, Christmas celebrations, office parties, weddings, weekend gatherings, or simply as an indulgent treat for no reason at all, this is the dessert people talk about long after the last slice disappears.

At over 5kg of pure banoffee goodness, the XL is big, bold, beautiful and unapologetically indulgent. This is the showstopper you bring when you want impact, flavour and guaranteed applause.

As a boutique weekend bakery, we make every XL pie fresh to order with premium ingredients and genuine small-batch care. Pre-order with 48 hours’ notice to secure your weekend or festive delivery.

---

Available In All Three Banoffee Flavours

Every XL Party Size pie is made with the signature layers that made Butter and Love a Sydney favourite, customised to your chosen flavour.

OG Banoffee
A buttery biscuit base, homemade dulce de leche, fresh Australian bananas, double thick vanilla bean cream and dark chocolate shavings.

Biscoff Banoffee
A caramel-spiced biscuit base layered with dulce de leche, fresh bananas and a creamy Biscoff swirl for warm, comforting flavour.

Peanut Butter Banoffee
Dark roasted crunchy peanut butter, dulce de leche, fresh bananas, double thick peanut butter cream, dusted with Dutch cocoa and topped with peanut brittle. If you love the perfect salty-sweet balance, this one will make your tastebuds do a victory lap.

---

Why Our XL Party Size Banoffee Pie Is Sydney’s Favourite Celebration Dessert

Every extra-large pie is a decadent masterpiece:

• Thick, Golden Biscuit Base – sturdy enough to hold over 5kg of pure indulgence

• Slow-Cooked Dulce de Leche – silky, rich and irresistible

• Fresh Australian Bananas – hand sliced on the day for peak ripeness

• Double Thick Cream (vanilla bean or peanut butter depending on flavour) – smooth, lush and cloud-like

• Finishing Touches – dark chocolate shavings, biscoff crumble or dutch processed cocoa and peanut brittle

Whether you’re choosing the classic OG, the comforting Biscoff, the crowd-pleasing Peanut Butter or the flawless OG GF, each pie delivers unbelievable flavour at spectacular scale.

This is the dessert that gets photographed, praised, inhaled and remembered.

---

XL Party Size Details – Built for Big Celebrations

XL / Party Size (12 inch / 30.5 cm)
Weighs over 5kg
Serves 20–26

Perfect for:

• Christmas lunches and festive dinners

• Corporate events and office parties

• Large birthday celebrations

• Engagement parties and pre-wedding gatherings

• Community events

• Family feasts requiring dessert diplomacy

• Anyone who believes bigger is better when it comes to Banoffee

---

Order Your XL Banoffee Pie – Fresh, Artisan, Unforgettable

Our home-based bakery operates on weekends only, with each XL pie handcrafted to order. Pre-order at least 48 hours in advance as quantities are limited.

• Collection: Five Dock, Sydney (address provided upon order confirmation)

• Delivery: Sydney-wide weekends, with midweek options available at a surcharge

• Special Requests: Perfect for office surprises, festive events or large gatherings

Sydney’s Best Banoffee Pie – baked with butter, love and legendary scale.

Order now (your future self will thank you).