0

Menu

A little slice of hap-pie-ness

Handmade with love in Sydney

Sydney's Best Banoffee Pie

One thing. Done ridiculously well.

PRE-ORDER PIESBUY SLICESReviews5.0 507 reviews ↗
Join the VIP list

Customer Love

  • “SO GODDAMN DELICIOUS”

    Emelia Jackson, Dessert Queen and Winner of Masterchef 2020

  • "Best dessert I’ve had this year!”

    Issac Martin @issac_eatsalot

  • "One of the best in Sydney. Butter and Love’s #banoffee is bomb.com"

    Jess@jess.xv.v

  • "This is the best banoffee pie I've had in my lifetime"

    Zac Kerr @counting

    _zacros

  • "The best Banoffee Pie I have ever tasted and I have tasted a few in my time”

    Head Pastry Chef, Four Seasons Hotel Sydney
Butter and Love's OG Banoffee PieButter and Love
The Original Obsession

Meet the OG.

Handmade Fresh-to-Order
Five Dock Pickup · Wed - Sat
Refrigerated Delivery · $29 Flat Fee
Four ways to fall in love

Choose your obsession.

Meet the pies →
Butter and Love's OG Banoffee PieThe Original

OG
Banoffee Pie

From $89.95

Classic. Indulgent. Fresh.

This is Peak Banoffee Romance.

3 sizes · Regular · Large · XLChoose size →
Biscoff Banoffee PieThe Biscoff Addiction

Biscoff
Banoffee Pie

From $94.95

Addictive. Caramelised crack.

Then Biscoff entered the chat...

3 sizes · Regular · Large · XLChoose size →
Peanut Butter Banoffee PieThe Nutty Obsession

Peanut Butter
Banoffee Pie

From $99.95

Salty. Sweet. Obsessed.

Crunchy. Layered. Unforgettable.

3 sizes · Regular · Large · XLChoose size →
OG Banoffee PieThe GF DreamGF

Gluten Free
Banoffee Pie

From $99.95

GF OG. GF PEANUT BUTTER.

All the GF love you can handle.

Regular · Large · XLChoose size & flavour →

Trying Sydney's Best Banoffee Pie! 😨

Good decisions, made easy

From our kitchen.
To your happy place.

For the birthday person, the office hero or the very deserving you.

01

Find your flavour.

OG, Biscoff, Peanut Butter or Gluten Free. Then pick the size your table deserves.

02

Make a date.

Pre-order at least 2 days ahead. Choose an available pickup or delivery date in your shopping cart.

03

Become everyone’s favourite.

Collect from Five Dock or have your pie delivered chilled to an eligible Sydney postcode.

Not a planner? Still a pie person.

Just follow
the crumbs.

Walk in for a slice at Five Dock. No pre-order, no occasion required. Earlier is safer. Self control is optional.

Find your slice →
Your local hap-pie place

Wednesday to Saturday10am - 4pm (or until sold out)

Shop 3, 223 Great North Road, Five Dock

Through the glass doors between
Eden Pasticceria and Dino’s Five Dock.
We’re on the right, directly behind Dino’s.

Hand-drawn Eden Pasticceria and Dino’s Café storefronts, with the arcade entrance between them.
OG Banoffee Pie
No shortcuts. No playing it safe.

Every layer.
A love language.

Toasted, golden, salty, buttery biscuit crumbs. Decadent caramel that takes its sweet time. Freshly sliced bananas. Clouds of real vanilla bean, double thick cream. Dark chocolate, lovingly curled by hand.

Nothing complicated. Just a frankly unreasonable amount of attention to getting it right.

  1. 01Toasted biscuit
  2. 02Luscious caramel
  3. 03Fresh Australian bananas
  4. 04Double thick vanilla bean cream
  5. 05Lovingly hand curled dark chocolate
Fall for the Original →