Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie

The Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie – Sydney's Most Decadent Twist

Handcrafted in Five Dock, Sydney, the Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie by Butter and Love is our ultimate twist on the classic Banoffee Pie. Customers have called it “dangerously addictive” and “ruined all other desserts for me”. Fair warning: everyone who tries this becomes a repeat customer.

Loved for birthdays, Christmas celebrations, office parties, weddings, weekend gatherings, or simply as an indulgent treat for no reason at all, this iconic dessert combines the rich flavours of peanut butter with the classic banoffee experience you already know and love.

If you adore that perfect dance between salty and sweet, this pie will have your taste buds waltzing. Dark roasted crunchy peanut butter, silky caramel, and lush peanut cream make every bite utterly irresistible.

As a boutique weekend bakery, we create each pie to order, ensuring maximum freshness. This is not mass-produced. It is artisan baking at its finest, made with premium ingredients and a whole lot of love. Pre-order with 48 hours’ notice to secure your weekend or festive delivery.

Why Our Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie Creates Instant Obsession

Every pie is a luxurious masterpiece:

• Buttery Biscuit Base – perfectly crisp foundation to hold all your dreams

• Dark Roasted Crunchy Peanut Butter Layer – bold, nutty intensity (smooth is for amateurs)

• Homemade Dulce de Leche Caramel – slow cooked for hours to create rich, indulgent toffee

• Fresh Australian Bananas – hand sliced on the day of pickup to ensure peak ripeness

• Double Thick Peanut Butter Cream – our secret-ratio PB cream that customers beg us to sell separately

• Dutch Processed Cocoa Dust & House-Made Peanut Brittle – because more peanut butter is always the answer

If you’re the type who eats peanut butter straight from the jar, believes Reese’s should be a food group, or thinks “too much peanut butter” is an oxymoron – this is your pie. One customer said it best: “This pie understands me on a spiritual level.”

Banoffee Pie Sizes – Perfect for Every Celebration in Sydney

• Regular (8 inch / 20cm) – approx. 1.8kg, serves 8–10
  Ideal for converting your friends to the peanut butter side

• Large (10 inch / 25cm) – approx. 3.0kg, serves 12–14
  Perfect for birthday parties, office celebrations, and festive dinners

• Extra Large / Party Size (12 inch / 30.5cm) – approx. 5.0kg, serves 20–26
  The showstopper that creates peanut butter disciples at every event

Order Your Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie in Sydney – Fresh and Artisan

Our home-based bakery operates weekends only (Saturday and Sunday pickup or delivery). Each pie is baked fresh to order. Pre-order at least 48 hours in advance to secure your pie. Limited quantities ensure every dessert receives personal attention.

• Collection: Five Dock, Sydney (address provided upon order confirmation)

• Delivery: Sydney-wide on weekends, with midweek options available at a surcharge

• Special Requests: Perfect for surprise office celebrations or weekend dinner parties

Pro tip: Order two – you’ll want one for yourself after everyone tries just a bite.

Why Butter and Love is Sydney’s Sweetest Weekend Ritual

This is not just dessert. It’s a gateway drug to peanut butter paradise. Made with zero artificial flavours, hand-finished with obsessive care, and baked in our home kitchen, every Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie is what happens when indulgence meets genius.

For peanut butter lovers, salty-sweet seekers, and anyone who believes life is too short for subtle flavours – this is your pie. Secure your artisan Peanut Butter Banoffee today and join Sydney’s most devoted dessert converts.

Perfect for Christmas, birthdays, festive parties, office functions, team meetings, weddings, or simply making your weekend extraordinary.

Sydney’s Ultimate Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie – baked with butter, peanut butter, love, and limited availability. Order now (your future self will thank you).