Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie

Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie Sydney – Peak Banoffee Romance with a Salty Sweet Obsession

Looking for the best banoffee pie in Sydney?
You just found it.

Handcrafted fresh in Newtown, Butter and Love’s Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie takes everything people love about the OG and turns it all the way up. With 400+ five star Google reviews and a cult following that reaches well beyond Sydney, this is the flavour that quietly becomes your favourite…then refuses to be replaced.

This is what happens when rich, dark roasted peanut butter meets peak Banoffee romance. Salty, sweet, creamy, crunchy and completely unapologetic.

Buttery biscuit base, luscious dulce de leche caramel, fresh bananas, double thick peanut butter cream and a generous layer of crunchy peanut butter. Finished with cocoa and house made peanut brittle for that final hit of texture.

Simple on paper. Unreal in real life.

Made fresh to order using premium ingredients and obsessive attention to detail, this isn’t just a twist. It’s a commitment.

This is peak Banoffee romance…in its most indulgent form.

Why Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie Hits Different

Every layer is doing the absolute most:

• Buttery Biscuit Base – toasted, golden and generously buttery, with just enough salt to keep things interesting

• Dark Roasted Crunchy Peanut Butter Layer – bold, nutty and unapologetically crunchy. Smooth was never invited.

• Homemade Dulce de Leche Caramel – slow cooked until deeply caramelised and dangerously moreish

• Fresh Australian Bananas – hand sliced just before pickup for perfect ripeness and texture

• Double Thick Peanut Butter Cream – rich, velvety and whipped to that just right cloud consistency

• Dutch Processed Cocoa Dust & House Made Peanut Brittle – a salty, bittersweet finish with crunch that pulls everything together

If you’re the type who eats peanut butter straight from the jar, believes Reese’s should be a food group, or thinks “too much peanut butter” is an oxymoron – this is your pie.

Banoffee Pie Sizes – Perfect for Every Celebration in Sydney

• Regular (8 inch / 20cm) – approx. 1.8kg, serves 8–10
  For “just a few slices"…and then suddenly it’s gone!
  

• Large (10 inch / 25cm) – approx. 3.0kg, serves 12–14
  Birthdays, dinners and showing off a little
  

• Extra Large / Party Size (12 inch / 30.5cm) – approx. 5.0kg, serves 20–26
  The centrepiece. The crowd favourite. The reason people ask who brought dessert.
  

Order Banoffee Pie in Newtown, Sydney

All pies are made fresh to order with a minimum 48 hours’ notice.

• Pick Up: Inside Rude Boy Doughnuts, 573 King Street, Newtown NSW 2042 

• Trading Days: Thursday to Sunday

• Time: 10am to 2pm

Pro tip: Order two. One for the table, one you don’t have to share.

Why Butter and Love

With 400+ five star Google reviews, Butter and Love has become a cult favourite for banoffee pie in Sydney.

We do one thing and do it exceptionally well.

This isn’t mass produced. It’s a one woman kitchen powered by butter, turning out pies people go out of their way for.

No shortcuts. No artificial flavours. No playing it safe.

FAQs

Where can I buy peanut butter banoffee pie in Sydney?
Right here. Butter and Love is based in Newtown with pickup available Thursday to Sunday.

Do I need to pre-order?
Yes. A minimum of 48 hours’ notice is required as every pie is made fresh to order.

Is it sweet or salty?
Perfectly balanced. Richer, saltier and more indulgent than the OG. 

Do you offer gluten free options?
Yes, gluten free options are available in all three sizes.

Sydney's Best Banoffee Pie

For peanut butter lovers, dessert obsessives and anyone who doesn’t do things by halves.

This is Sydney’s best banoffee pie…a full blown salty sweet obsession.

Order now…before you see it on someone else’s story and regret everything.