Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie Sydney – Peak Banoffee Romance with a Salty Sweet Obsession

Looking for the best peanut butter banoffee pie in Sydney?

You found your problem.

Butter and Love's Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie takes everything people are obsessed with about the OG and turns the indulgence all the way up. Handcrafted in Five Dock, Sydney's Inner West and backed by 450+ five star Google reviews, this is the flavour people order once...then quietly start comparing every other dessert to.

Rich dark roasted peanut butter. Luscious homemade dulce de leche caramel. Freshly sliced Australian bananas. Thick peanut butter cream clouds. Dutch cocoa. House made peanut brittle.

Salty. Sweet. Creamy. Crunchy.

Completely unapologetic.

Made fresh to order with love, zero shortcuts and a frankly unreasonable commitment to peanut butter.

This isn't just a twist on the OG.

This is peak Banoffee romance...with a salty sweet obsession.

---

Why This Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie Hits Different

Every layer is doing the absolute most.

Buttery Biscuit Base
Toasted, golden and generously buttery, with just enough salt to keep things interesting.

Dark Roasted Crunchy Peanut Butter Layer
Bold, deeply nutty and unapologetically crunchy. Smooth was never invited.

Homemade Dulce de Leche Caramel
Slow cooked until deeply caramelised, glossy and dangerously moreish, with that signature banoffee toffee richness.

Fresh Australian Bananas
Hand sliced just before pickup for perfect ripeness, freshness and texture.

Double Thick Peanut Butter Cream
Rich, velvety and whipped to that just right cloud consistency, with dark roasted peanut butter folded through every bite.

Dutch Processed Cocoa and House Made Peanut Brittle
Deep cocoa, salty crunch and a bittersweet finish that pulls every outrageously indulgent layer together.

If you eat peanut butter straight from the jar...
believe Reese's should be a food group...
or think "too much peanut butter" is an oxymoron...

This is your pie.

Sound like your kind of obsession? Pre-orders are open now.

---

Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie Sizes for Birthdays, Parties and Zero Restraint

Regular – 8 inch / 20cm
Approx 1.8kg | Serves 8–10

Perfect for "just a few slices"...another beautiful theory.

Large – 10 inch / 25cm
Approx 3kg | Serves 12–14

Birthdays, dinner parties and making the peanut butter person in your life question every dessert that came before it.

Extra Large / Party Size – 12 inch / 30.5cm
Approx 5kg | Serves 20–26

The centrepiece. The crowd favourite. The reason people suddenly become very interested in who is cutting the slices.

---

Order Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie in Five Dock, Sydney's Inner West

Every Butter and Love Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie is made fresh to order.

Curbside Pickup – Five Dock (address provided upon order confirmation)
Trading Days – Wednesday to Saturday
Pickup Times – 10am to 5pm
Delivery – Sydney delivery available to selected postcodes

A minimum of 48 hours' notice is required.

I only take a limited number of orders each week. Once the diary is full, it's full.

Pro tip: order enough to share.

Or don't.

I'm a baker, not a relationship counsellor. 😂

---

Why Butter and Love?

One thing.

Done really well.

Because some things shouldn't be rushed.

Butter and Love was built around an obsession with creating exceptional Banoffee Pie and refusing to cut corners along the way.

Then peanut butter got involved.

This isn't mass produced.

There are no conveyor belts, giant production lines or sad little tubs of cream waiting around for days.

It's a tiny business powered by butter, love and an alarming number of bananas.

Every pie is made fresh with premium ingredients and obsessive attention to the details that most people would probably tell me to calm down about.

I will not be calming down.

The result? Sydney's best Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie.
The world felt legally ambitious.

450+ five star Google reviews.

A loyal following across Sydney (...Newcastle, Brisbane and Melbourne 👀)

And a Banoffee Pie people genuinely go out of their way for.

No shortcuts.

No mass production.

No playing it safe.

Just buttery biscuit, luscious dulce de leche caramel, dark roasted peanut butter, fresh bananas, peanut butter cream clouds, deep cocoa, house made peanut brittle and absolutely no interest in subtlety.

---

Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie FAQs

Where can I buy Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie in Sydney?

Right here. 👋🏼

Butter and Love is based in Five Dock in Sydney's Inner West, with curbside pickup available Wednesday to Saturday.

Sydney delivery is also available to selected postcodes.

Do I need to pre-order?

Yes.

Every Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie is made fresh to order and requires a minimum of 48 hours' notice.

Weekend and celebration dates regularly book ahead, so early ordering is strongly recommended.

Particularly if you've already promised someone peanut butter.

They will remember.

Is the Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie sweet or salty?

Both.

Exactly as nature intended.

It's richer and saltier than the Original, with dark roasted peanut butter balancing the dulce de leche caramel, fresh banana and vanilla bean cream.

The Dutch cocoa adds bitterness. The house made peanut brittle adds crunch.

Salty sweet equilibrium achieved.

Can I order Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie for a birthday or event?

Absolutely.

You can select your preferred available pickup or delivery date at checkout.

Our Regular, Large and Extra Large Peanut Butter Banoffee Pies are perfect for birthdays, dinner parties, celebrations, corporate events and people whose preferred measurement of peanut butter is "more".

How long does Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie last?

Your Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie is best enjoyed within 3 days.

Always keep it refrigerated and remove it from the fridge approximately 20 to 30 minutes before serving.

That's when the base softens, the peanut butter relaxes, the flavours open up and peak Banoffee romance really starts doing its thing.

If I pick up my Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie the day before my event, will it still be fresh?

Absolutely.

Your Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie will be perfect for up to 3 days when kept refrigerated and enclosed.

In fact, a lot of customers tell me it tastes even better the next day as the flavours settle and deepen overnight.

So yes. Pick up Saturday. Serve Sunday.

Whether it survives Saturday night is between you and the pie.

Do you offer gluten free Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie?

Yes.

Gluten free Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie is available in all three sizes.

---

Sydney's Best Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie

For peanut butter lovers.

Salty sweet obsessives.

Dessert maximalists.

People who don't do things by halves.

Or anyone who has ever eaten peanut butter directly from the jar and felt absolutely no shame.

This is Sydney's best Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie, made fresh in Five Dock, Sydney's Inner West, with butter, peanut butter, love and zero restraint.

450+ five star reviews can't all be your mum.

Pre-order yours now...
before you see it on someone else's story and regret every decision that led you to not having a slice.