Peanut Butter Banoffee Pie

Crunchy. Layered. Unforgettable.

Salty. Sweet. Obsessed.

★★★★★Five star Google reviewsThey can’t all be my mum. ↗

$119.97 AUD · Tax included

Free Five Dock Pick upRefrigerated Delivery$29 Flat Fee

A toasted buttery biscuit base, dark roasted crunchy peanut butter, luscious homemade dulce de leche, fresh Australian bananas and double thick peanut butter cream. Finished with Dutch cocoa and house made peanut brittle. Smooth was not invited.

HalalAlcohol FreeEgg FreePasteurised DairyVegetarian Friendly

REAL CUSTOMER LOVE

What people say about this pie

★★★★★

“My personal favourite is the Peanut Butter Banoffee. It’s so good, it should be illegal.”

Amrapali SidhwaniGoogle review · Read full review ↗

★★★★★

“Went with the extra fancy peanut butter version and what can I say…the crunch, the creaminess, the slight saltiness from the peanuts…to die for!”

Greta BinschGoogle review · Read full review ↗

★★★★★

“Now it’s peanut butter banoffee pie or nothing and I don’t know who I am anymore.”

Bobby HendryGoogle review · Read full review ↗

Pick up & delivery

Made fresh. Pre-order AT LEAST 2 days ahead

Free Five Dock Pick upShop 3/223 Great North Rd
Five Dock (Sydney’s Inner West)Wednesday - Saturday,
10am - 4pm (or until sold out).

Refrigerated Delivery · $29 Flat FeeEligible Sydney postcodes. Delivered chilled.Check delivery areas ↗

Check your area and live availability here. Confirm your Pick up or delivery date in the shopping cart before checkout.

1Choose your pieFlavour and size

2Check live availabilityAt least 2 days ahead

3Pick your exact dateFinal date is chosen in cart

Check your postcode & live availability

Quantity

Good things take a little notice.Pre-order at least 2 days ahead.Your future self will thank you.

Handmade in Five Dock. Worth making plans for.

Good pie. Very good decisions.

Crunchy. Layered. Unforgettable. A toasted buttery biscuit base, dark roasted crunchy peanut butter, luscious homemade dulce de leche and fresh Australian bananas. Double thick peanut butter cream clouds, Dutch cocoa and house made peanut brittle finish the job. Built from the bottom up. Subtle from absolutely no angle.

For the person who eats peanut butter straight from the jar and thinks “too much peanut butter” is an oxymoron. Handcrafted fresh to order in Sydney’s Inner West. Order enough to share. Or don’t. I’m a baker, not a relationship counsellor.

01Why this pie? The salty sweet balance.

The crunch: toasted, salty, buttery biscuit base, dark roasted crunchy peanut butter and house made peanut brittle.
The caramel: rich house made dulce de leche.
The freshness: freshly sliced, perfectly ripe Australian bananas.
The clouds: double thick, dark roasted peanut butter cream.
The finish: generous dusting of Dutch processed cocoa; dark, earthy and bittersweet against all that glorious indulgence.

Salty. Sweet. Crunchy. Creamy. A textural punch in the face. Smooth peanut butter was not invited to the party.

Contains peanuts. Need a gluten free base? Choose GF Peanut Butter. It still contains peanuts and is made in our shared kitchen.

02Sizes: how many people does a whole pie serve?

Regular: 8–10 serves · 2kg
Large: 12–14 serves · 3kg
X Large / Party Size: 22–28 serves · 5kg

Serving a crowd? Choose for your guest list, then allow for the person who “only wants a tiny slice”. You know the one. Serves depend on how generously you cut.

03Pick up & delivery: when and where can I get my pie?

Every whole pie is made fresh to order. Pre-order at least 2 days ahead and choose an available date. A pie for Sunday? Collect on Saturday and keep it boxed and refrigerated.

Free Five Dock pick up: Wednesday - Saturday, 10am - 4pm (or until sold out), at Shop 3/223 Great North Rd, Five Dock NSW 2046.

Enter the glass doors between Eden Pasticceria and Dino’s Five Dock. We’re on the right, directly behind Dino’s. Find us.

Refrigerated Sydney delivery: $29 flat fee to eligible postcodes. Check your area and availability above, then confirm your date in the shopping cart before checkout. See delivery areas and details.

04Pie care: how long will it stay fresh?

Keep your pie boxed and refrigerated. Best enjoyed within 3 days. Remove it from the fridge 20–30 minutes before serving. The caramel relaxes. You take the credit.

Collecting the day before your celebration is absolutely a plan. Leaving it on the bench all afternoon is not. More pie questions, answered.